• Home
  • About
  • CLYDE'S BOOKS
  • 1970 Revo at 50
  • DISCUSSION
  • You and the Law
  • Tobago Self-Government
    • CW Submissions to JLSC
WELCOME TO CLYDE WEATHERHEAD'S SITE
| HOME |  CLYDE'S BOOKS  |  CONTACT CLYDE  |
Picture

Platform Talk 6: Analysis Paralysis

7/12/2019

 
To paraphrase Kitch’s popular Carnival cooldown tune - The Elections are Over.
While the music trailers and trucks and the car p.a. systems are silent; while the motorcades and rallies are in hibernation, the narratives on LGE 2019 roll on.
In the absence of full preliminary or final results from the EBC, including the allocation of all Aldermen in the various Corporations by what is described as an ‘element of proportional representation’ in the First Past The Post electoral process, claims and counter-claims of victory, speculations and pure mischief are afoot.
VERY PRELIMINARY RESULTS
On Monday night as the votes were being counted what was most apparent was that the 2-party political monopoly (some say duopoly) remains dominant in the governance system (electoral and political processes) as they exist.
The PNM-UNC political monopoly survives.
The other parties which fielded candidates in total received less than 1.5% of the votes cast, the MSJ and PPM with 26 and 12 candidates respectively got most of those votes.
Rowley declared – We Win! We get more seats (never mind is less seats than they got in 2016).
Persad-Bissessar declared – We Win! We win the popular vote (never mind the popular vote does not really matter in FPTP electoral processes).
And, the Corporations won moved from 8:6 to 7:7 – Whaaaat! A Tie.
So, the latest controversy for the spin doctors on both sides to pounce on is Who Win?
Of interest was how many of the 1,079,976 electors actually came out to cast their votes in these elections. There were 139 elections in that number of Districts (2 more than in 2016) in 14 Regional Corporations. The media were reporting a turn-out of 22-23%, until the EBC said on Tuesday evening, but it was 34.49%, a par score as LGEs go, a mere 0.35% more than 2016.
This meant that a bit more than 65% of the electors were not motivated to come out and stain their fingers in this election for the 2-party monopoly. That was significant.
INTERESTING DEVELOPMENTS
Amid all the Who Win speculation, and while several recounts were proceeding, the EBC issued titled - The Preliminary Results for the 2019 Local Government Elections.
What was unusual was not the fact that preliminary results were issued. That has been done up to the LG by-elections last year, 2018.
These preliminary results while giving a breakdown of votes cast for each party in these elections did not disclose either the number of the 139 elections (Districts) won by which party nor the votes obtained in each.
The most unusual thing about these particular preliminary results was this phrase – “…The United National Congress received the popular vote…”. I don’t recall the EBC ever using that language as the body conducting FPTP electoral processes for over 57 years. (Perhaps I’m wrong and someone will disabuse me of my misgiving).
The media, on the other hand, were busy fuelling the PNM-UNC fire with counts of ‘seats’ (sic) and Corporations won; “Arima – 7-0, 7-7 Draw” the headlines screamed. This only helped to confuse some citizens who apparently still are not aware of how our electoral system works.
PLAYING ON IGNORANCE
Playing on the ignorance of the workings of the process, a mischievous conspiracy theory was later unleashed with the EBC as its target.
“No UNC votes in Port of Spain, Diego Martin and San Juan-Laventille were counted or recorded” was the claim by at least 3 social media video propagandists and repeated by several posters.
When I asked in a non-scientific poll on social media, if people believed or disbelieved this story, the answers were instructive.
Of course, there were the usual red or yellow trolls who defended their parties.
The fact that the EBC had already issued the total votes for all parties; the fact that UNC was able to secure an Alderman in Diego Martin for the first time since 2010 which was only possible if they got 25% of the votes at least, didn’t raise alarms about the obvious falsehood.
I blame the EBC and the media and the political parties for failing to conduct the political education of the electorate so that people understand the process in which they are asked to participate as their “civic” or “democratic duty, etc.
Political parties are only interested in having voters get them into office by going and staining their fingers for their parties for their self-serving ends. Electors need to exercise an INFORMED vote.
Hopefully, the EBC does its job and gets the preliminary and/or final results out quickly so that people have FACTS to go on and all the speculation and inane propaganda is silenced as quietly as the music trucks, p.a. systems and platforms have been.
Let us get to seriously analysing and learning the lessons of this electoral exercise and demand the reforms that are needed to bring about Democratic Renewal of the Electoral and Political Processes to give the 65% majority and more a Real Say in Decision-making that Affects their Lives.

Clyde Weatherhead
A Citizen Fighting for
Democratic Renewal of
Our Society and Empowerment of
the People.
6 December 2019

    Author

    I am a appalled at the loss of the simple skills of discussing ideas and sharing Opinions to DEEPEN ANALYSIS and UNDERSTAND DEVELOPMENTS to ARRIVE AT SOLUTIONS.
    Read my Blog - Where De We Go, TT?

    Archives

    April 2024
    September 2022
    August 2022
    June 2022
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    January 2016

    Categories

    All
    Economics
    Governance
    Politics

    RSS Feed

Picture
About Clyde Weatherhead

Clyde has been involved in public life as a political activist, a trade unionist, Lawyer, Teacher and Author

Connect With Clyde

Write to Clyde

on Facebook

Visit Clyde's Author Page on Amazon  

Go To Discussion on Facebook

For Employment Relations Issues 



(c)  copyright 2015 ClydeWeatherheadsite.net                                                                                                                                                                          Web Hosting by iPage
  • Home
  • About
  • CLYDE'S BOOKS
  • 1970 Revo at 50
  • DISCUSSION
  • You and the Law
  • Tobago Self-Government
    • CW Submissions to JLSC